The Duplicity of Clara

From her beginning, Clara has been a character of two identities, which I find interesting. In Asylum of the Daleks, she was Oswin Oswald and she was a Dalek. In The Snowmen, she was Clara Oswin Oswald, the barmaid, and Miss Montague, the nanny. In The Bells of Saint John, we learn that Clara is subbing in as a nanny because her friend, the children’s mother, has died. But, that isn’t really what she does. Throughout Season 7b, Clara and the Doctor are repeatedly confronted by Claras from other times. Only at the end of the season do we learn she had been seeded throughout the doctor’s timeline.

Now, in Season 8, Clara is again living a double life. At times she is a school teacher and Danny’s girlfriend, and at other times she is traveling the universe with the Doctor. She has been lying to both men in one way or another the entire time. And now, after Flatline, we find out that she has been chosen by Missy for some purpose.

This character has never been what she seems. I am reminded how Prisoner Zero in the Eleventh Doctor’s first episode, Eleventh Hour, told the Doctor that “Silence will Fall.” Even though we met and apparently completed The Silence story-arc during the Sixth Season, their true nature and the full meaning of “Silence will fall” was not revealed until Eleven’s final episode, The Time of the Doctor more than two years later. Moffat faked us out. I am beginning to wonder if we aren’t being lead around by Moffat again.

Maybe, we will find out that Missy in some way had influence over Clara being seeded throughout the Doctor’s timeline. Clara did initially (timey wimeyness at work here) contact the Doctor because she was given his number by a woman (likely Missy) in a shop before she was seeded into his timeline.

Perhaps being the Impossible Girl was not the penultimate truth of Clara. What if Clara is more than she appears?

What would be a totally cool, new way for a companion to be a companion?

There is a history in New Who of the companions emulating the Doctor and becoming more Doctor-like. With Donna, she became the DoctorDonna. Clara is pretty explicitly walking down this path. Is this standard companion fare, or is Clara’s story-arc leading to a different kind of ending? Perhaps Clara’s future involves some form of evolution on her part. She has had greater contact with the time vortex and time streams than any other companion, except maybe River. How has this changed her? Is she more than human?

Don’t you love trying to figure out what Moffat has going on before all is revealed? It is one of my favorite past times.

Totally superfluous question to create the appearance that this blog has value: How are you more than one?



Let's Talk...What Do You Think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.